Award winning debut novel The Spinning Heart by Donal Ryan promised an interesting read. I often find that books of such fame are either hated or loved by myself. I found this to be an interesting read – both in its content and in its method of delivery.
It tells the story of a rural community experiencing huge changes after the death of the Celtic Tiger. ?The building boom has ended, work has dried up, the local builder employer has left the country leaving debts and a partially finished ghost estate. His employers find they aren’t entitled to unemployment benefits as he never paid their PRSI. Events include a murder, an abduction and the surfacing of many grudges.
Each chapter is written as recounted by a different character. In some ways, I wished to hear from a particular character again but I have to admit that most questions were answered by the end of the novel – it didn’t leave me with a frustrated unfinished feeling! The first chapter is by the ex-foreman of the building company and although there are many unanswered questions that I would like him to answer, I found this did happen in the last two chapters partly because his wife is the teller of the story in the final chapter.
The book does have echoes of Patrick McCabe which is a strength. ?I also like the way the characters are so interlinked to each other and yet have their rivalries or perhaps don’t even realise how closely they are related. ?We hear from a prostitute with grown children, we wonder who is actually a brother of who, without them even knowing. The age-old plotlines of fathers being cruel to sons, of not communicating, of beating pride out of them, of Irish mammies trying to do their best, the single mothers unsure of the fatherhood of their child, the tie of the land, the hatred of the tie of the land – these are all recognizable themes that so many Irish people will empathise with.
One thing that struck me was how young men and students were not allowed to do well in school – either because education wasn’t valued by a parent, that pride in doing well was seen as a sin, or that they knew their peers would beat the hell out of them for being a ‘swot’. ?I can remember lads being bullied for being top of the class. ?I remember my dad saying how he got 19 sums right out of 20 in an exam once and how frustrated he was to have got one wrong as he knew the answer – imagine if his parents had derided him for it – as happened to so many. ?I think of my son and daughter and their pride when they do well in a test. I remember how the bus driver told me once how Will was so excited about coming home and showing me his ‘star of the week’ badge, telling the bus driver that his mum would be so proud of him. Cruelty by parents to a child would make your heart break – be it real or fictional.
It gives a window into life in many communities in post Celtic Tiger Ireland, the shock and disbelief at the collapse, the large mortgages that couldn’t be paid, the ghost estates, the resentment, the necessity of emigration, the anger, the tensions. It’s a very perceptive and well written novel. Yes, I would certainly recommend it. I read it last weekend in two sittings and could scarcely put it down. It’s a novel that will stay with me.
Pingback: Sunday Book Review: The Thing About December by Donal Ryan « The Irish Farmerette
Yes, I has just lost my job when I started it, so the first chapters felt rather close to home. I thought the book is spectacular, though.
The whole atmosphere of being suspect for getting an education or doing well at school was something I couldn’t stand when I was younger. Now trying to keep that attitude away from my girls.
Me too and it seems fine in primary school, it’s good to get 100%. I wonder how it will change in secondary school.
To be beaten for doing well though and by a parent – isn’t that extreme? Well, I know the factor saw it as pride and was vicious anyway but there were probably many like him.
Lorna, enjoyed your review. His other book ‘The thing about December’ is a great read, possibly even better than ‘The Spinning Heart’. I’m looking forward to Donal Ryan publishing more.
So impressed with your goal to read 52 books a year Lorna! I can never read enough but it so interferes with my housekeeping which is basically a big joke anyway. The Spinning Heart sounds most excellent and I’m going to have my library track it down. thanks for the great review.
Thanks Donna – I love reading and this is the only way I can get to do it – by making it a goal. I read quite quickly though. I have about ten books on my ‘must read and review’ list – no pressure. Now that I’m getting to know more authors too, I really want to read their books
Sounds interesting Lorna – not a book I’d especially look forward to reading but one that might ‘be good for me’. It’s always useful to have different perspectives about Irish communities given that I work closely with them.
It’s not comfortable reading but it offers a great insight into life post Celtic tiger. I’ve a feeling we’re going to see lots of novels set in that era now 🙂
BUY THE BOOKS NOW
Subscribe to My Blog Posts
Subscribe to My Newsletter